The Wooden's Wisdom Logo

Motivate Your Team! Cheer Up A Friend! Inspire Yourself!

Issue 730 - "Do you want him on the team or not?" (Accountability)

Woodens Wisdom
Wooden's Wisdom - Volume 13 Issue 730
Craig Impelman Speaking |  Championship Coaches |  Champion's Leadership Library Login

"DO YOU WANT HIM ON THE TEAM OR NOT?" (ACCOUNTABILITY)

 
 
Every time one of us went to Coach Wooden to complain about a difficult player, he never began with discipline, strategy, or consequences. Coach always asked the same question:
 
"Do you want him on the team or not?"
 
I got that question from Coach whether I was asking him about a disgruntled basketball player, unhappy salesperson or an effective but difficult to deal with manager.
 
Dozens of coaches who visited him got that same question.
 
And the moment he asked it, everything changed.
 
We would walk into his home ready to vent about attitude, inconsistency, stubbornness, or body language. We thought we were coming for a lesson on accountability. What we got instead was a lesson on decision-making.
 
Coach understood something leaders sometimes overlook:
 
You cannot decide how to hold someone accountable until you decide whether you want them on the team or not.
 
If the answer was no, the accountability was simple: remove them.
 
If the answer was yes, then Coach would help us work backward to create a plan that protected:
 
  • the person’s dignity
  • the team’s standards
  • and the leader’s integrity
 
This wasn’t soft accountability. It was flexible accountability — accountability that adapts to the person without lowering the team’s standards. Accountability to teach not punish.
 
Coach modeled this constantly.
 
On the 1964 championship team starting forward Jack Hirsch called Coach Wooden "John," not "Coach." Coach Wooden let him do it — because it didn’t affect his performance, character or team play. Hirsch was unhappy about the number of shots he was getting compared to Gail Goodrich, so Coach gave him a little something back.
 
Bill Walton wanted long hair. Coach Wooden didn’t lecture him; he simply said:
 
"I respect your right to stick up for what you believe in and we’re going to miss you." When Walton got a haircut, it was his choice.
 
This was the same principal President Eisenhower used with Nikita Khrushchev during the Cold War: Eisenhower never embarrassed Khruschev in front of his country. Never take away a person’s dignity. Always give them a graceful way out.
 
Accountability without dignity becomes control.
 
 
Accountability with dignity becomes leadership.
 
The greatest basketball coaches ever: John Wooden, Phil Jackson, Red Auerbach — all understood the same truth:
 
Keeping great talent engaged is harder than just disciplining them.
 
If you want someone on the team, your accountability must match their value without compromising your standards. If you mistreat the people you want to keep, you won’t keep them.
 
When we walked into Coach’s home, we wanted an answer.
 
What we got was responsibility.
 
Before you decide how to hold someone accountable, you should decide:
 
Do you want them on the team or not?
 
 
 

Yours in Coaching,
 
 
Craig Impelman
 
 
 
 


 

 

 

Watch Video

Application Exercise

COACH'S FAVORITE POETRY AND PROSE

 

Show Me

I would rather see a Mason, than hear one any day,
I would rather one would walk with me than merely show the way.
The eye's a better pupil and more willing than the ear,
Fine counsel is confusing, but example's always clear.
And the best of all the Masons are the men who live their creeds,
For to see the good in action is what everybody needs.

I can soon learn how to do it if you'll let me see it done,
I can watch your hands in action, but your tongue too fast may run.
And the lectures you deliver may be wise and true,
But I'd rather get my lesson by observing what you do.
For I may misunderstand you and the high advice you give,
But there's no misunderstanding how you act and how you live.

Edgar Albert Guest (1881-1959)

 

 

 

 

 

For more information visit www.woodenswisdom.com

 

Enter a list of email addresses, separated by spaces, to send this issue to.

Email a Friend

Return to Issue List


Our Services
Why Wooden's Wisdom
Presentation Team
Wooden's Wisdom Leaders
Leadership Resource Center
Member Login

© Copyright 2025 WoodensWisdom.com | # of Times Wooden's Wisdom Issues Opened: 7,763,790

Hosting & Design by:EverydayWebDesign.com